Many species teach us. This one has done that repeatedly. It keeps teaching.
The savanna blazing star (Liatris scariosa var. nieuwlandii) has tried to teach us slow learners at Somme Prairie Grove from 1989 through 2026. This post will summarize some of what we've come to understand over the past 37 years. We didn't learn through proper controlled experiments that could be published in the academic journals. And yet, we learned.
Lesson 1.
For decades, this plant failed to thrive. It either survived in small numbers where we seeded it or the various little populations died out. But now it's spreading widely to new areas. Why the change? There are at least three likely reasons.
The first reason is that we have increasing amounts of the habitat that this species thrives in - what we have begun to call "lo-pro" habitats. In "low profile" plant communities, most plants are relatively short and spaced out. The opposite of lo-pro is stands of rank saw-tooth sunflower, tall goldenrod, woodland sunflower, etc.
Most high quality prairies or woodlands are relatively lo-pro in the sense that their diverse and conservative vegetation is shorter than in otherwise similar "degraded" sites. Somewhat grazed-out pastures can be remarkably low-pro in that the species that have settled in for the long haul are short statured and leave bits of open ground between them. (Species in this situation include aliens Canada blue grass, wild carrot, and daisy along with natives like poverty oats, early goldenrod, and strawberry.) Under the right conditions of light and moisture, the savanna blazing star seems to readily establish by seed in both types of low-pro communities.
We now have a good deal more lo-pro at Somme Prairie Grove as a result of a) time for conservatives to gradually win out, b) broadcast of seed mixes which in recent years have a larger representation of conservative species and c) widespread cutting back of aggressive species with scythes or other mowers. It is in these areas that the savanna blazing star is spreading.
A second reason for its increasing numbers is that this species may have sorted its alleles to better adapt on conditions at Somme. We've noticed this phenomenon in many species. They survive in small numbers for many years and then increase rapidly. It's as if their genes have finally figured out the right combinations for conditions at this site.
A third reason could be simply that there's a lot more seed blowing around. Perhaps there's no great principle involved. Perhaps it's just chance, waiting for the right weather conditions for a species, coinciding with a lot of seed everywhere. Or perhaps the people who broadcast seed mixes every fall are doing a better job deciding where to broadcast the seed of this species. One argument against this simple explanation is that we see this species in places where we would not have chosen to broadcast seed.
To provide a few numbers, for the first five years of this blazing star blooming at Somme Prairie Grove, we counted an average of 8 blooming plants. For the second five years we found an average of 18. During the most recent five years our count has averaged 479. Will this species thrive here over the long haul? After 37 years, it's still much too early to even hazard a guess. But what a pleasure to study what happens!
Lesson 2.
The savanna blazing star seems to be highly fire dependent. More plants bloom in the growing season following a fire than in other years. The graph below shows an example. The data reflects the numbers of plants per year in a part of the preserve that was burned every second year. In some non-burn years, fewer than ten plants bloomed. In some burn years, more than eighty bloomed in this location.
We are not the first to notice larger numbers blooming after a fire. As I remember (though I can't find the reference on line) Timothy Bell demonstrated this phenomenon years ago. But our data confirmed it for this population under these conditions.
Lesson 3.
The savanna blazing star can be somewhat faithful to a narrow range of stable habitats, where conservatives are common, resources are heavily used, and competition is tough. Such areas are most stable where partial shade limits both the tall prairie grasses (too shady for them) and the standard woodland species (too bright for them). These habitats had been dominated by rank species until recently, when we realized that a few seasons of "mowing the thugs" allows more diversity to establish.
These areas could be contrasted with an unsuccessful strategy pursued in our early years with this species. We included this species in planting lists for bare ground areas where brush had been cut. Large numbers were blooming after a few years. But if there was no shade and thus dense tall prairie grasses flourished, this blazing star failed to compete and gradually died out.
Lesson 4.
These plants, compared to many Somme species, seem to be short lived and move around the site in response to changing conditions. Could that fact reflect merely that the site is "rapidly" evolving due to restoration? Or if its transitory nature is part of this plant's adaption to "the savanna dynamic."
Fire adapted wooded communities need species tailored to situations where trees growing are increasingly expanding shaded areas - and also to situations where trees blow down or burn off. Perhaps this species is adapted in part to such areas.
We learn as we work. We have not planted this species by individually raised young plants or root plugs. We've broadcast seeds widely and let the plants prosper where they will. We thus try to focus more on the ecosystem than on the species.
As Reed Noss wrote:
There is widespread agreement that conservation at the ecosystem level will be more efficient and cost-effective than a species-by-species approach … Biodiversity is threatened at all levels, virtually everywhere. A pluralistic conservation strategy centered on ecosystems may be our best hope to turn the tide.
Standard biology assembles what it knows on the basis of facts verified by experiment. That's good and right, but there is no way to use that process to reach certainty on many important questions about a Nature Preserve or any ecosystem, given that much depends on interactions among hundreds of species of plants and thousands of species of animals and other biota within a variety of hydrologies, soils, slopes, aspects, etc. And all is changing, as species evolve, the climate warms, air quality and composition degrades or improves, and new species enter the fray. What could be truly demonstrated by scientific experiment some time ago might not be true under current conditions. Thus, as biodiversity conservationists, we try to do this work based on principles different from standard science. Some claim we're just old-fashioned gardeners. Others that what we're doing is an "art." One possible perspective is that holistic experimental restoration is a discipline in its early stages that may mature into "a science" at some point ... but will be more like medical science than like physics.
Where the Savanna Blazing Stars are:
Critically imperiled in New York and West Virginia.



No comments:
Post a Comment